Learning which makes a difference* Q Sort for Students* Creativity Q sort

Learning which makes a difference* 

Carl Rogers On Becoming a Person. "Significant Learning: In Therapy and in Education"

By significant learning I mean learning which is more than an accumulation of facts. it is learning which makes a difference -- in the individuals behavior, and the course of actions he chooses in the future, and his attitudes and in his personality. it is a pervasive learning which is not just an accretion of knowledge, but which interpenetrates with every portion of his existence. 280

Speaking of this reminds me of a forceful statement made by a professor of agronomy in my freshman year in college. whatever knowledge I gained in his course has departed completely, but I remember how, with World War 1 as his background, he was comparing factual knowledge with ammunition. he wound up his little discourse with the exhortation don't be a damned ammunition wagon; be a rifle! I believe most Educators would share this sentiment that knowledge exists primarily for use. 281  

here are some additional thoughts about learning

Carl Rogers "personal thoughts on teaching and learning"

At this juncture I took off for Mexico and one of our winter quarter trips, did some painting, writing, and photography, and immersed myself in the writings of Soren Kierkegaard. I'm sure that his honest willingness to call a spade a spade influenced me more than I realized. 273 

So I sat down to write, is honestly as I could, what my experiences had been with teaching, is this term is defined in the dictionaries, and likewise my experience with learning. I was far away from psychologists, educators, cautious colleagues. I simply put down what I felt, with assurance that if I had not got it correctly, the discussion would help me to set it on the right track. (274)  

List of thoughts:

Is a consequence, I realize that I'm only interested in being a learner, preferably learning things that matter, that have some significant influence on my own behavior. I find it very rewarding to learn in groups in relationships with one person as in therapy, or by myself. I find that one of the best, most difficult ways for me to learn is to drop my own defensiveness, at least temporarily, and try to understand the way in which his experience seems and feels to the other person. 

I find that another way of learning for me is to state my own uncertainties, try to clarify my puzzlements, and thus get closer to the meaning that my experience actually seems to have. 276 

 

Q Sort for Students*

from ChatGPT

Great! Here's a student-centered version of Carl Rogers' Q-sort with 40 cards—adapted for use in high school or college settings. These statements are phrased in accessible language and focus on areas relevant to students: self-image, relationships, motivation, emotions, school identity, and personal growth.

---

🎓 Student Q-Sort Card Set (40 Cards)

💬 Relationships & Social Identity

1. I try to be kind to others.

2. I care what people think of me.

3. I have at least one person who really gets me.

4. I often feel left out or invisible.

5. I get along well with most people.

6. I avoid letting people see the real me.

7. I compare myself to others a lot.

8. I’m a good friend.

9. I feel like I don’t fit in.

10. I can be myself around others.

🧠 Self-Understanding

11. I know who I am.

12. I feel pulled in different directions.

13. I feel comfortable in my own skin.

14. I act differently depending on who I’m with.

15. I like who I’m becoming.

16. I pretend to be someone I’m not.

17. I feel confused about what I believe.

18. I feel proud of who I am.

19. I often doubt myself.

20. I’m still figuring myself out.

📚 School & Motivation

21. I care about doing well in school.

22. I often procrastinate.

23. I try my best even when things are hard.

24. I just try to get through the day.

25. I like learning new things.

26. I don’t really see the point of school.

27. I’m easily distracted.

28. I feel motivated to improve.

29. I avoid tasks that make me uncomfortable.

30. I can focus when I need to.

🌊 Emotions & Inner Life

31. I’m good at handling stress.

32. I often feel anxious or overwhelmed.

33. I try to hide my emotions.

34. I feel okay asking for help.

35. I often feel pressure to be perfect.

36. I feel calm and balanced most of the time.

37. I get stuck in negative thoughts.

38. I feel confident about the future.

39. I often feel like I’m not enough.

40. I’m learning to accept all parts of myself.

---

🃏 How to Use It

1. Give each student a printed version of the 40 statements (on cards or slips of paper).

2. Have them do two sorts:

   • Real Self: "How true is this of me right now?"

   • Ideal Self: "How true would I like this to be of me?"

3. Sort into a quasi-normal distribution, e.g.:

Very Untrue     Slightly Untrue     Neutral     Slightly True     Very True  
    (-2)               (-1)             (0)          (+1)             (+2)  
     6                  10              8             10               6

(Adjust the number per column to fit 40 cards.)

4. After sorting, students can:

   • Reflect in writing about areas of congruence/incongruence

   • Choose 2–3 cards from each side and journal about why they placed them there

   • Discuss in pairs or small groups (if appropriate and comfortable)

---

Would you like me to create a PDF version for printing or a digital version for Google Slides or Docs? I can also provide a reflection worksheet to go with it.

Creativity Q-Sort

Absolutely! Here's a Q-sort set of 40 cards focused on creativity, designed to explore a person’s creative self-concept—how they perceive themselves as a creative person now vs. how they’d ideally like to be.

This version works beautifully for:

• Students in creative writing or art classes

• Adults exploring identity or growth

• Coaching, therapy, or self-reflection

• Anyone reflecting on their relationship with creativity

---

🎨 Creative Identity Q-Sort (40 Cards)

💭 Imagination & Originality

1. I often imagine things that don’t exist yet.

2. I enjoy coming up with unusual ideas.

3. I think outside the box.

4. I often surprise myself with my ideas.

5. I see connections between things other people don’t.

6. I daydream regularly.

7. I’m good at generating ideas.

8. I often get stuck in conventional thinking.

9. I feel like I’m not a very original thinker.

10. I think creatively in most areas of my life.

🔧 Making & Doing

11. I create things regularly.

12. I finish the creative projects I start.

13. I often have ideas but don’t follow through.

14. I enjoy tinkering, sketching, writing, or building.

15. I turn my ideas into real things.

16. I wish I made more time to create.

17. I make something just for the joy of it.

18. I rarely act on my creative impulses.

19. I like experimenting with different materials or tools.

20. I get frustrated when things don’t turn out perfectly.

🌀 Risk & Uncertainty

21. I take risks in my creative work.

22. I’m okay with not knowing how something will turn out.

23. I fear being judged for my ideas.

24. I’m willing to try and fail.

25. I hesitate to share my creative work.

26. I feel exposed when I show my ideas.

27. I can tolerate the messiness of the creative process.

28. I avoid creative work if I’m unsure of the outcome.

29. I’d rather be safe than bold in my creativity.

30. I feel confident putting unusual ideas out into the world.

🌱 Growth & Identity

31. I see myself as a creative person.

32. I used to feel more creative than I do now.

33. I believe creativity can grow with effort.

34. I compare my creativity to others and feel behind.

35. I feel creatively stuck.

36. I want to develop my creative voice.

37. I’m learning to trust my creative instincts.

38. I feel energized when I’m creating.

39. I am just beginning to explore my creativity.

40. I am becoming the kind of creative person I want to be.

---

💡 How to Use It

Ask participants to sort the 40 statements twice:

1. Real Creative Self – “How true is this of me now?”

2. Ideal Creative Self – “How true do I want this to be?”

Sort into categories from –2 (Very Untrue) to +2 (Very True), like this:

Very Untrue   Slightly Untrue   Neutral   Slightly True   Very True
   (–2)             (–1)           (0)         (+1)          (+2)
    6                10             8           10             6

Then reflect on:

• Where is there alignment between real and ideal?

• Where is there a gap?

• What’s one small creative risk you’d like to take this week?

---

Would you like:

• A printable version (PDF or DOCX)?

• A reflection worksheet?

• A Google Slides template for digital use?

Just say the word!